The dollar strengthened and commodities fell today as word of a more gradual QE2 asset purchasing program repriced investor expectations. Gold closed down 1%. This market reaction hurt GG and SLW today, but I saw a parallel to something I'm learning in class that could possibly reassure our decision to purchase gold and silver companies.
--
A simple concept I'm learning in my financial management class is pricing a stock as the sum of the present value of earnings and the present value of growth opportunities.
In formula form: p= [EPS/r] + PVGO
p= price
EPS= earnings per share
r= discount rate
PVGO= present value of growth opportunities
Basically, EPS/r is a term that assumes a company paying out all its earnings as dividends forever (i.e. none reinvested in the company- no growth), discounted at the appropriate discount rate. PVGO is a residual term that accounts for any money a company doesn't pay out (in other words, "plowback") and reinvests in itself. The formula for PVGO is a little complicated, so it's easier to treat it as a residual to analyze investor sentiment. For example, if you have the current price of the stock, EPS, and r, you can find PVGO.
One way to think about PVGO is as a premium investors put on the price over the current earnings based on speculation of future growth.
--
Applying this to today's markets, as soon as news of a more gradual and less "dollar doomsday" QE2, the essential PVGO of gold and other inflation-hedges dropped. This makes sense because investors like us bought these commodity companies and drove their prices up in future anticipation of a falling dollar.
So does this mean that all future expectations are already priced into gold, silver, and the like? If so, does gold and silver have much more room to run?
I think it's unreasonable to say QE2 has been fully priced in until it happens. There's not much basis for investors to compare QE2 to (besides a failed QE1) and I believe once it actually happens, GG and SLW will reap the benefits.